An Honest AnswerPsalm 51:6

The Answer I Hate Hearing Myself Say

This message is for the woman who gives the same cheerful eight word answer at the school gate every morning and hates hearing herself say it

Oh, you know. Head down, getting on with it.

Eight words. She has been saying them since about March and she says them beautifully now, with a small laugh at the end that closes the conversation without being rude, and she despises them.

It happens at the gate, mostly. Somebody says how are you doing, in the tone that means they know, and out it comes. Head down, getting on with it. She has said it to her neighbor, to the woman who runs the after school club, to her own aunt on the phone, and once, memorably, to a doctor.

The problem is not that it is a lie. It is not a lie. Her head is down. She is getting on with it. The problem is that it is a door, and she built it, and now she cannot open it even for people she would like to let in.

She heard herself say it on Tuesday to a friend who had actually stopped walking and turned to face her, which is a thing people almost never do, and she gave that woman the eight words and watched her nod and move on, and got into the car and put her hands on the wheel.

You have eight words. Maybe yours are shorter. Everybody who has been through something has a phrase that has worn smooth, and the smoothness is the trouble.

The Answer I Hate Hearing Myself Say

Say what the eight words have cost

Nobody has counted this, and it should be counted before we go near a better sentence.

They have cost her the friend on Tuesday, at least for now. They have cost her the version of her aunt who would have driven over. They cost her, in March, a doctor's appointment that could have gone differently. And they have cost her something harder to see: after six months of saying a thing that is true and not true at the same time, she has started to lose track of which one it is.

That is the real damage. Not deception of other people. A slow blurring of her own inside.

You have been paying for a door you built in a hurry, and God has never once been on the far side of it. Psalm 139:2 says He understands your thought from far off, and the same Spirit is the one who takes that off a page and puts it in a car at ten past nine with the hands still on the wheel. The eight words have never worked on Him and He has never once asked her to stop using them.

Truth in the inward parts, which is where it starts

There is one line built for a woman who has stopped being able to find her own answer.

Behold, you desire truth in the inward parts: and in the hidden part you shall make me to know wisdom.Psalm 51:6

Notice where the truth is wanted. Not truth in the reporting. Truth in the inward parts, which is the place the eight words have been quietly eroding. God is not asking her to be more forthcoming at a school gate. He is asking to be let into the room where she keeps what is actually happening, and the Holy Spirit is the one who makes that an invitation rather than an audit.

You have a place inside where the truth is wanted rather than assessed, and it was opened to you rather than earned. That is not a lovely reading of a penitential psalm. The written word puts the desire on His side and the inward parts on hers, and the Spirit is the one who makes being known there feel like relief rather than exposure.

And I want to be plain about something. Your honest sentence is not a witnessing technique. It is not a way to open a conversation about faith at a school gate. Nothing here is asking you to be a good example to your neighbor, and what she does with your answer is not your responsibility and never was.

What a true sentence actually looks like

Here is the design constraint, and it is narrower than people think. It has to be true, it has to be sayable in about four seconds, and it must not put you on display.

Which rules out both of the things she has been choosing between all year. The eight words fail the first test. Telling somebody at a gate how bad February really was fails the third, and she knows it, and that is why she never does it.

What is left is a sentence like: honestly, it is a hard stretch, and I am all right. Or: not my best week, but I am here. Or, on a Tuesday when somebody actually stops and turns: it is harder than it looks, thank you for asking.

You are allowed to hand somebody a true thing without handing them the whole thing, and that is not a compromise. Proverbs 4:23 says to keep the heart with all diligence because out of it are the issues of life, and it is His Spirit who makes keeping and telling into two different things a woman is allowed to hold at once.

One plain sentence before we go on. If the hard stretch has gone somewhere darker, if there are hours where carrying on is genuinely a question, please tell one real human being today and use more than four seconds, and if it is urgent, call your doctor or a crisis line first. That is not a failure of the sentence. That is what the sentence is for, arriving properly, and reaching for it is obedience rather than collapse.

The breakthrough

So write one down. That is the whole of it.

Not to use on everybody. The eight words are fine at the gate and you can keep them; a street runs on doorstep answers and there is no virtue in dismantling that. Write one true sentence, in your own words, for the person who stops walking and turns round.

You have a true sentence and it does not put you on show, and both of those things can be true at once. Psalm 51:6 is the ground under that, not my sympathy, and it is the Holy Spirit who takes a written line and makes it something a woman can actually say out loud on a Tuesday.

And when you say it, you are finished. What the other person does with it is theirs. You are not responsible for their comfort, their follow up question, or whether they know what to say next.

You are known in the inward parts already, and nothing you say at a gate adds to it or takes anything from it. Psalm 139:1 says searched and known, and the same Spirit who wrote that was in the car with you at ten past nine.

Declare this over yourself

Say these out loud in the kitchen. Christ is in you and you are in Him, and the truth in the inward parts was given to you, so the authority to say what is actually happening is yours and it does not belong to a school gate. Scripture is the ground here, not my sympathy, and His Spirit is the one who makes a line like this land in a woman who has been saying the same eight words since March. However He answers about the hard stretch, the outcome is His, and managing what anybody does with your answer was never a job He handed you.

  1. Cheerful eight words at the gate, you do not get to speak for me any more. Psalm 51:6 says the truth is wanted in the inward parts, which is exactly the room those eight words have been wearing down.
  2. Fear that a true sentence would make me a spectacle, you do not get to write my answers. Four honest seconds is not a display, and in the name of Jesus the Holy Spirit is holding what I have been holding behind a door I built in March.
  3. Lord, You desire truth in the inward parts and You have never once been on the wrong side of that door. Your word says You know my thought a long way off. I thank You, and I have written one true sentence down and it is in my coat pocket.

Why we ask you to say these out loud

The word this stands on

Psalm 51:6

This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.

More Manna

Psalm 34:18
An Honest Answer

Fine At The Graveside

An Honest Answer9 minCaleb
Psalm 34:18
Ephesians 4:25
An Honest Answer

Four Words At The Coffee Machine

An Honest Answer8 minAmir
Ephesians 4:25
2 Corinthians 4:7
An Honest Answer

One True Sentence Is Enough

An Honest Answer10 minNova
2 Corinthians 4:7
Mark 9:24
An Honest Answer

Teach Me To Have What You Have

An Honest Answer9 minImani
Mark 9:24
2 Corinthians 12:9
An Honest Answer

The Answer I Performed At The Breakfast

An Honest Answer9 minJubilee
2 Corinthians 12:9
Proverbs 27:6
An Honest Answer

The Emoji I Sent Back At Midnight

An Honest Answer8 minZariah
Proverbs 27:6
Proverbs 12:19
An Honest Answer

The Joke I Use Over The Fence

An Honest Answer9 minElias
Proverbs 12:19
Psalm 62:8
An Honest Answer

The Reflex Answer In The Corridor

An Honest Answer9 minTahoma
Psalm 62:8
Psalm 32:2
An Honest Answer

The Summary I Gave At The Reunion

An Honest Answer9 minZev
Psalm 32:2
Colossians 3:9
An Honest Answer

Three Words For Everybody

An Honest Answer9 minEliana
Colossians 3:9
Psalm 78:4
An Honest Answer

What I Owe My Daughter At Fourteen

An Honest Answer9 minSantiago
Psalm 78:4
Psalm 27:5
Strong Refuge

A Bed She Has Not Slept In

Strong Refuge9 minEliana
Psalm 27:5
John 1:48
Fully Known

Before You Say A Word

Fully Known10 minTahoma
John 1:48
1 Samuel 7:12
Kept Standing

A Ledger That Should Have Closed

Kept Standing9 minEliana
1 Samuel 7:12
Psalm 23:2
Free To Rest

Emergency Contact For Six People

Free To Rest9 minTahoma
Psalm 23:2
Genesis 32:26
His Own Doing

Arguing With God Since April

His Own Doing9 minImani
Genesis 32:26
Psalm 92:14
Wholly At Home

A Church That Reorganized Around Young Families

Wholly At Home9 minEliana
Psalm 92:14
Psalm 91:1
Strong Refuge

Eleven Minutes In The Parking Garage

Strong Refuge10 minAmir
Psalm 91:1
Psalm 34:15
Fully Known

I Stopped Ordering Hot Drinks

Fully Known9 minNova
Psalm 34:15
Psalm 37:24
Kept Standing

Eleven Weeks I Cannot Account For

Kept Standing8 minMelody
Psalm 37:24
Galatians 6:2
Free To Rest

Four Years Since Anybody Prayed For Me

Free To Rest8 minImani
Galatians 6:2
James 1:5
His Own Doing

One Sentence I Read Once

His Own Doing9 minAmir
James 1:5
Psalm 90:1
Wholly At Home

Eight Moves And No Home Town

Wholly At Home9 minMelody
Psalm 90:1
Psalm 4:8
Strong Refuge

Sunday Night And Monday Already Started

Strong Refuge9 minNova
Psalm 4:8
1 Samuel 16:7
Fully Known

Looked At And Then Looked Past

Fully Known8 minElias
1 Samuel 16:7
Zechariah 4:6
Kept Standing

Four Hospital Years And Still Kind

Kept Standing8 minImani
Zechariah 4:6
Matthew 11:28
Free To Rest

Nine Years Without Being Ill In Front Of Anybody

Free To Rest9 minMelody
Matthew 11:28
Ephesians 4:32
His Own Doing

The Forgiveness I Have Not Finished

His Own Doing8 minSantiago
Ephesians 4:32
Psalm 91:9
Wholly At Home

I Leave Every Party At Nine

Wholly At Home9 minNova
Psalm 91:9
Nahum 1:7
Strong Refuge

The Barn That Burned In March

Strong Refuge9 minElias
Nahum 1:7
Psalm 33:13
Fully Known

Table Nine And The Whole Room Deciding

Fully Known8 minSantiago
Psalm 33:13
Psalm 40:2
Kept Standing

How I Got To The Window Every Day

Kept Standing8 minNova
Psalm 40:2
Psalm 61:2
Free To Rest

The Calm One Crying In A Parking Lot

Free To Rest9 minNova
Psalm 61:2
Titus 3:5
His Own Doing

The Gentleness And The Thing I Wanted To Say

His Own Doing8 minTahoma
Titus 3:5
John 15:19
Wholly At Home

The Only Believer At The Family Meal

Wholly At Home9 minSantiago
John 15:19